Thanks for the replies, everyone.
To answer questions - These guys have been good - they do use cheap bikemaster seals - the first pair I had lasted at least 12-13k miles and many wheelies and 2-up rides on crappy roads. The second set lasted about 7 months - then the right side started leaking, followed soon by the left. Their wait time was a little long, so I took it to my local garage mechanic, who is certified and usually does a great job. Got the bike back and it felt fantastic, but started leaking on the right seal two weeks later, then the left. He said the bikemaster seals suck, so I ordered genuine myself and brought them to the original dealer. Because it was only 7 months they gave me a deal (their warranty is 6 months) - only half price on labor, so it wasn't much to get them installed. However, the right seal started again.. I'm sure they will honor it as I've been a regular customer for quite some time and bought a couple bikes from them in the past, and mainly, because if there were any pitting they are supposed to warn me - since that would allow them wiggle room on the warranty. However, they didn't.
I read in another forum of a guy with a C14 who had fork seals leak at 20k (I'm currently at 22-23k without looking) - specifically, the right side - had it replaced, same thing happened, then replaced the fork and was good till 58k (still hadn't blown, but was his current mileage.)
I can inspect closely tonight, but the forks always looked pretty good. My guess is maybe they needed to go a little deeper and use some fine steel wool followed by polish and they probably didn't do all that.. still awaiting a call back from them.
The seals were purchased from BikeBandit, so I would believe they'd have a warranty - didn't even think about that.. I'll check it out.
Any other advice is appreciated! What's the absolute best way to polish up forks? They should be absolutely straight, I don't know why they keep leaking on that right side.